The ongoing NCAA Settlement has garnered significant attention in the media, but recent rule changes are also expected to reshape how current and future NCAA athletes navigate the recruiting process. Key updates involve eligibility for Division I athletes with junior college (JUCO) experience and adjustments to NCAA Division II recruiting regulations. Below, we break down these changes and their implications for student-athletes.

JUCO Student-Athletes Receive NCAA Eligibility Waiver

As of December 23rd, The Division I Board of Directors approved a blanket waiver granting an additional year of eligibility to former junior college transfers.

This decision followed a federal court ruling in favor of the current quarterback for Vanderbilt University, Diego Pavia, who argued that his time at New Mexico Military Institute should not count toward his NCAA eligibility. His legal team compared his experience to athletes at preparatory academies or junior hockey programs, highlighting the disparity in NIL opportunities between JUCO and Division I levels. The NCAA sent a memo about a week after the ruling that stated:

“The NCAA Division I Board of Directors granted a waiver to permit student-athletes who attended and competed at a non-NCAA school for one or more years to remain eligible and compete in 2025-26,” the NCAA memo reads, “if those student-athletes would have otherwise used their final season of competition during the 2024-25 academic year, and meet all other eligibility requirements (e.g., progress toward degree, five-year period of eligibility).” (ABC News)

Initially applicable only to Pavia, the NCAA extended this waiver to all non-NCAA school student-athletes, including JUCO and NAIA institutions. Eligible athletes who would have exhausted their NCAA eligibility in 2024-25 can now compete for an additional year in 2025-26, provided they meet other requirements such as academic progress and adherence to the five-year eligibility clock. 

The NCAA has indicated plans to appeal Pavia’s court ruling, leaving the long-term impact of this waiver uncertain. However, for now, JUCO and NAIA athletes now have an opportunity to extend their playing careers.

Implications for Future Student-Athletes 

This decision offers exciting prospects for former JUCO and NAIA athletes but adds challenges for high school athletes aspiring to Division I programs. If the ongoing NCAA settlement reduces roster sizes in 19 of 43 sports, competition for roster spots will intensify. Next season has already become increasingly competitive for thousands of high school student-athletes with Division I aspirations, and this could lead to even fewer available roster spots across many sports.

Here at SportsRecruits, we advocate casting a wide net when creating your target list of schools. Exploring options across all divisions can maximize recruiting opportunities, especially in a more competitive landscape. 

Additionally, reports suggest the NCAA is considering extending eligibility to five years for all athletes. This would be another significant change for the NCAA, as the 2024-2025 academic year marks the final season in which student-athletes can use the extra year of eligibility provided during the 2020-2021 season due to the COVID-19 pandemic. While no timeline for a decision has been announced, this potential change could further impact eligibility rules for JUCO and NAIA athletes. We will monitor the situation closely and provide an update when it is available. 

Final Thoughts 

With new eligibility rules, the college recruiting process continues to evolve. Staying informed and proactive can help student-athletes adapt and make the most of their opportunities at any level of competition. Whether you’re a current JUCO athlete or a high school freshman exploring your options, the key is preparation and a broad perspective on potential pathways.

Want to stay up to date on all things recruiting, including NCAA updates like this? Follow us on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube!

About SportsRecruits

SportsRecruits is the leading college recruiting network, connecting athletes, clubs, high schools, and college coaches in the recruiting process. Every year, millions of connections are made between student-athletes and college coaches in our network, resulting in thousands of commitments to the best academic and athletic institutions.

Sign up for a free profile today:
https://app.sportsrecruits.com/signup

Sign up your club or high school today:
https://sportsrecruits.com/club/signup

Login to discover athletes as a college coach:
https://my.sportsrecruits.com/colleges/getstarted